Key Takeaways
- Schiff said Selig promised to defer to courts on sports contracts but told companies to ignore them.
- Nominees Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland said they would follow a Supreme Court ruling on the issue.
- The Senate Agriculture Committee did not vote on either nominee, and the record stays open two business days.
Schiff Says Selig Was ‘Anything but a Blank Slate’
The Senate Agriculture Committee held the hearing on Nov. 17 for Republican Nathan Anonick and Democrat Matthew Rowland, both of whom President Donald Trump nominated to the CFTC last week. Selig has been the agency’s only commissioner since he was confirmed in December 2025.
Schiff (D-Cal.) recalled asking Selig at his own confirmation hearing whether a prediction market contract on a football game was sports betting. Selig, he said, told him he would be a “blank slate” and would look to the courts.
“I don’t know whether he was just lying to us or once he was confirmed he had some sort of an epiphany, but he’s been anything but a blank slate,” Schiff said. Instead of deferring to the courts, he said, Selig “has filed briefs to tell the courts what to do” and “has basically told companies to ignore the courts.”
“I don’t know if I’ve ever been so blatantly deceived by a nominee before,” Schiff said. “This is not the kind of leadership we need at the CFTC.”
Schiff led a letter from nine Democratic senators to Selig on Nov. 16, a day before the hearing, asking the agency to withdraw or freeze its Nov. 5 interpretation telling exchanges to drop state geoblocks, arguing it conflicts with court orders. The CFTC has sued several states, including Arkansas, to stop them from applying gambling laws to federally regulated exchanges. “The CFTC will continue to defend its sole jurisdiction over these federally regulated markets as granted by Congress under the Commodity Exchange Act,” Selig said about the suit prior to the hearing.
The Nominees Wouldn’t Call Sports Contracts Bets
Schiff was the one who put the same question to Anonick, asking whether a prediction market bet on Thursday’s NFL game between the Indianapolis Colts and the Houston Texans is a sports bet. Anonick said the question is “complex” from a legal perspective and that federal courts have disagreed on it.
“If betting on who wins a football game is not a sports bet, can you tell me what a sports bet is?” Schiff asked. Anonick again said courts have disagreed on the question. Asked whether he would defer to the courts, he said he would “fully support” the CFTC following a Supreme Court decision on the issue. He added that he had no “preconceived position” on the litigation.
Sen. Tina Smith, a Minnesota Democrat, pressed both nominees on the same point, arguing that a contract that “quacks like a bet” is a bet, echoing an argument states and tribes have repeatedly made in court. Rowland said courts have ruled both ways and that it was hard to comment on active CFTC litigation, but that he understood her argument as a matter of practicality and was “sympathetic to the concerns the states and tribes have raised.” Anonick said he would not want to “tip the scales” and called it a “charged, emotional issue,” adding that he would hear from everyone who wants to be heard.
“I don’t think this is an emotional issue, it is a legal issue,” Smith replied, adding that it was “unambiguous” that a prohibition on gaming applies to the contracts, which she said were bets by another name.
Rowland also said he expects a Supreme Court decision “sometime within the next term or the one after.” In his written statement, he said “explosive growth in new markets for event contracts, crypto derivatives, and security futures,” driven by retail customers, “calls for the CFTC to reexamine and strengthen its customer protection rules.”
Senators Also Press on Staffing and Trump Family Ties
Other Democrats focused on the agency’s capacity and independence. Sen. Michael Bennet of Colorado said the number of listed contracts had grown 167% since 2024 while the CFTC lost 25% of its staff. Rowland called appropriate staffing “a very high priority,” and Anonick told other senators he would support an appropriately resourced commission. In his opening statement, Rowland said he wants to bring the enforcement program “back to its historical size.”
Sen. Raphael Warnock of Georgia said the CFTC under Selig “has repeatedly sued states to block regulation of companies that the president’s own son invested in and advised,” referring to Kalshi, a company which has repeatedly sued states to block regulation of companies that the president’s own son invested in and advised.” Donald Trump Jr. has advised both Kalshi and Polymarket, where his firm 1789 Capital is an investor, and left his Kalshi advisory role last week by mutual agreement.
When asked whether a company’s ties to the president or his family should affect how the agency treats it, Rowland said, “I think the law needs to be enforced fairly, without fear or favor, so the answer is no.” Anonick said, “The law should apply equally and fairly to everyone.”
The committee did not vote on either nomination immediately after the hearing. Chairman John Boozman said the record would remain open for two business days. The committee has not yet scheduled a vote.
